At least part of the extra £20bn a year the government has promised for the NHS should come from additional taxes on wealth, according to a new report from the campaigning organisation Tax Justice UK (TJUK).
Ahead of the budget later this month, the organisation is calling on the government to raise corporation tax, abolish entrepreneurs’ relief, reform council tax, make older workers pay National Insurance Contributions (NICs), curb the pension subsidy for the wealthy, and tax income from wealth at the same level as income from work. Together these proposals would raise over £23bn.
“A clear majority of the UK public support increasing tax to help fund the NHS. This is a golden opportunity for the government to reform the tax system so that wealth tied up in property and other assets is taxed fairly,” said Robert Palmer, CEO of Tax Justice UK.
In June 2018, Theresa May announced an extra £20 billion a year for the NHS by 2023. She promised that part of this would come from ‘fair and balanced’ tax increases. The NHS is facing rising costs due to an aging population, increasing obesity, and expensive new treatments.
Estimates suggest that just to maintain the current service, spending will have to rise by 3.3% annually for the next 15 years, with increases of 4% per year if services are to be improved. This represents an extra £95 - £124 billion by 2033-34 – a lot more than the Prime Minister promised.
In the current political and economic climate, further cuts to other government budgets such as defence, local authorities and housing would be difficult. Tax rises will have to form part of the solution to the NHS’s needs, and TJUK argues that the government should look beyond the three main taxes: income, VAT and National Insurance.
The organisation proposes four guiding principles to determine which taxes should go up: companies and the wealthiest should pay their fair share to ensure trust in the system; tax should increase in proportion to a person’s wealth and income; a sustainable tax system needs to look beyond increasing taxes on just those at the top and companies; and the poorest should be protected from tax rises.
In line with these principles it suggests raising the corporation tax rate to 20%, which would generate £8.4bn, abolishing entrepreneurs’ relief, which would raise £2.7bn, taxing income from wealth at the same level as income from work, which could raise £4bn, reforming council tax to more accurately reflect real property values, which would raise £5bn, applying NICs to earnings of those older than the state pension age, which would raise £1.3bn, and curbing the pension subsidy to the wealthy, which would raise £2bn. In total these reforms would raise £23.4bn a year.
Robert Palmer: “Our proposal is just one way in which the government could raise taxes to fund the NHS and promote a more equal and fairer society. Any reforms along these lines would need to be accompanied by greater efforts to clamp down on tax avoidance and evasion. Ultimately this should be seen as a real opportunity to have a broader debate about the level of public services we want and how to pay for them.”
Contact: Amy Barry on 07980664397 or firstname.lastname@example.org; Oliver Courtney on 07815 731889 or email@example.com; or Robert Palmer on 07817406618 or firstname.lastname@example.org